back

Profiling (In)justice

Disaggregating Data by Race and Ethnicity to Curb Discriminatory Policing

If you suspend your transcription on amara.org, please add a timestamp below to indicate how far you progressed! This will help others to resume your work!

Please do not press “publish” on amara.org to save your progress, use “save draft” instead. Only press “publish” when you're done with quality control.

Video duration
00:28:25
Language
English
Abstract
This talk will focus on the potential ability of data disaggregated by race and ethnicity to reduce discriminatory policing in Germany. In the UK, data has been collected during police procedures, allowing for a monitoring and evaluation of discriminatory policing practices. Unfortunately, such an empirically driven policy approach is not currently possible in Germany. This talk will argue that, as a first step, a policy based off the UK approach towards data collection be implemented in Germany to incorporate, rather than ignore, Germany’s diverse identities, and to allow for empirically driven and more effective policing.

As social exclusion and racial discrimination are highly tied to policing practices, it is essential that a reduction of discriminatory policing be part of the larger discussion on addressing social inequalities in developed nations. In Germany, the lack of data disaggregated by race and ethnicity means that there are no figures on the extent of racially or ethnically based discrimination. Germany presents a unique case for examining the collection of disaggregated data due largely to the term race, or Rasse, having negative connotations due to the misuse of such data during the Nazi era.

This talk will focus on the potential ability of data disaggregated by race and ethnicity to reduce discriminatory policing in Germany, with a particular focus on ‘stop and search.’ Stop and search is a crime-prevention practice existing in both Germany and the UK which allows police officers to stop individuals they suspect of committing a crime, carrying a weapon, possessing stolen property, or carrying drugs. In Germany, federal police have the added power to stop a person suspected of committing an immigration violation.

In the UK – due to pressure from civil society organisations, academics, and government officials – data has been collected during police procedures, allowing for a monitoring and evaluation of discriminatory policing practices. Unfortunately, such an empirically driven policy approach is not currently possible in Germany. This talk will argue that, as a first step, a policy based off the UK approach towards data collection be implemented in Germany to incorporate, rather than ignore, Germany’s diverse identities, and to allow for empirically driven and more effective policing.

Talk ID
7264
Event:
32c3
Day
2
Room
Hall 6
Start
4 p.m.
Duration
00:30:00
Track
Ethics, Society & Politics
Type of
lecture
Speaker
Jeff Deutch
Talk Slug & media link
32c3-7264-profiling_in_justice

Talk & Speaker speed statistics

Very rough underestimation:
157.4 wpm
894.7 spm
158.1 wpm
896.1 spm
100.0% Checking done100.0%
0.0% Syncing done0.0%
0.0% Transcribing done0.0%
0.0% Nothing done yet0.0%
  

Work on this video on Amara!

Talk & Speaker speed statistics with word clouds

Whole talk:
157.4 wpm
894.7 spm
datapeoplepolicestoppedcensustimediscriminationtermsquestionratecollectingstopsukgermanyhigherethnicityracethingsgroupsareasratesracialstatenationalcourtleveljeffcalledprofilingperceivedblackwhitekindsisn’treleasedcollectedcommunitiessecondtimestermcollectdemographicmakingdifficulttalkingprivacyfeelpersontalkratio
Jeff Deutch:
158.1 wpm
896.1 spm
datapeoplepolicestoppedcensustimestopsratetermscollectinghigherraceethnicitydiscriminationukthingsgermanyracialareasgroupsratescalledcourtstatenationallevelblackwhiteprofilingpersone.gbackgroundprivacytermcollectedquestiontimesisn’trightstrendscategoriesgermandifficulthappeningratiodemographicpopulationeuropeanmakingkinds